I borrowed my husband’s SUV while my car was at the mechanic’s. Then my lip balm rolled beneath his seat. When I reached down to grab it, I pulled out something that made no sense. Liam’s reaction when he called made one thing clear: I wasn’t supposed to find what was wedged underneath the seat.

I was sitting in the grocery store parking lot when my lip balm slipped into the narrow gap beside Liam’s driver’s seat.

“Perfect,” I muttered.

When I reached down to grab it, I found something that made no sense.

My own car was at the mechanic getting new brakes, so Liam had handed me his SUV keys that morning without hesitation.

That was normal for us.

What wasn’t normal was finding anything beneath his seat.

—

Liam treated that SUV better than some people treated their living rooms.

He vacuumed it every weekend, wiped dust off the dashboard, and had once made me finish a granola bar in our driveway because crumbs were apparently “how civilization collapses.”

I unbuckled my seat belt and pushed my hand into the gap.

My fingers brushed metal.

“Got you.”

Except it wasn’t my lip balm.

I pulled out a brass key with a blue rubber cap.

My heart started beating faster.

It wasn’t our house key.

I leaned down again and felt something soft wedged beneath the seat rail. A small zippered key pouch had fallen open.

Three more keys lay beside it.

Red. Green. Yellow.

All ordinary brass keys, each marked with a different colored rubber cap.

I found my lip balm wedged behind the seat rail, but the keys had my attention now.

I sat upright and lined them across my thigh.

Liam didn’t own rental properties.

He didn’t manage apartments.

We had no storage unit.

And I knew exactly where our spare house keys were.

I reached beneath the seat one more time.

This time I found a small hardware-store receipt folded in half.

Three duplicate keys.

Paid for at 8:14 that morning.

So one key was older.

Somehow, that felt worse.

Then my phone rang.

Liam.

I answered.

“Hey,” he said cheerfully. “Did you make it to the grocery store?”

“Yeah.”

“Good. Don’t forget coffee.”

“Liam?”

Something in my voice must have registered because he went quiet.

I picked up the blue key.

“Why are there four keys underneath your driver’s seat?”

The silence was heavy.

Then Liam asked, “Which ones?”

I sat back. “Which ones?”

“Oh, God. Meryl, that’s not what I meant.”

“Apparently you have enough secret keys that color coding matters.”

“They aren’t secret.”

“They’re under your seat.” I looked at the receipt. “And you had them made this morning.”

“Meryl, put them back exactly where you found them.”

I actually laughed.

“That is the worst possible thing you could’ve said.”

“I know how it sounds.”

“No, I don’t think you do.”

“They don’t belong to anyone you’re thinking about, Meryl.”

“You have no idea what I’m thinking about.”

“Yes, I do.”

“Then tell me who they belong to,” I demanded.

He didn’t.

For a moment, I felt ridiculous interrogating my husband over a handful of keys.

Then his silence stretched on.

“Are these women’s keys?” I asked.

“What? No!”

“Then whose?”

“Meryl…”

“Five years, Liam. Have I ever gone through your phone?”

“No.”

“Checked your email? Asked where you were every five minutes?”

“God, no… stop… please…”

“Don’t make me feel silly for asking why my husband has four strangers’ keys hidden in his car.”

“I’m not.”

“Then answer me.”

His voice suddenly changed.

“Please don’t drive home yet.”

“Why?”

“Because I haven’t finished.”

“Finished what?”

“I’ll explain. Just… meet me somewhere.”

That was the moment the situation stopped feeling strange and started feeling serious.

Continue reading